How To Address Overpayments From the Social Security Administration

Many individuals rely on their Social Security benefits to meet essential needs, and the prospect of having to repay funds can create significant financial strain (not to mention stress!). Whether it’s due to a change in circumstances or an administrative error, you need to take prompt and informed action when addressing an overpayment. If you find yourself worrying, “How do I pay back an overpayment from social security?” and don’t know what steps you need to take next, know that you’re not alone.

Pekas Smith: Arizona Disability Attorneys are here to help you navigate the complexities of overpayments, ensuring your rights are protected while offering clear, actionable guidance.

What Constitutes an Overpayment?

An overpayment occurs when the Social Security Administration (SSA) pays you more benefits than you can receive under the law.

Upon detecting the overpayment, Social Security issues a Notice of Overpayment to the individual receiving the disability benefit. Social Security overpayment letters specify the amount of benefits that have been mistakenly paid out and instruct the recipient to refund the surplus benefit within 30 days.

Often, overpayment doesn’t happen by accident, and there are various causes.

Common Causes of SSA Overpayments

The most prevalent causes of overpayment include:

      1. Failure To Report Changes in Circumstances

Many SSA overpayments occur when recipients fail to report changes in their circumstances to the SSA. This may include changes in:

  • Income
  • Employment status
  • Marital status
  • Disability status
  • Living arrangements

     2. Administrative Errors

Sometimes, the SSA makes mistakes and administrative errors, which lead to overpayments.

These errors could include miscalculating benefits, incorrect data entry, or misinterpreting eligibility criteria.

     3. Continuation of Benefits After Eligibility Ends

In some instances, individuals may continue to receive benefits after their eligibility has ended due to changes in their circumstances or failure to notify the SSA of changes on time.

      4. Changes in Financial Circumstances

Changes in financial circumstances, such as failure to report ownership of a life insurance policy that can be converted into cash value, may result in an overpayment.

Identifying an SSA Overpayment

The SSA typically notifies beneficiaries of overpayments through Social Security overpayment letters. These notices usually specify the amount owed, the reason for overpayment, and any actions the recipient needs to take to resolve the issue.

Unfortunately, receiving a notice of SSA overpayment can be incredibly stressful, particularly if the recoupment is across several payments and you were not aware of the overpayment.

Luckily, there are some key indicators to help you identify an overpayment so you don’t have to face this difficulty:

  • Discrepancies in Benefit Amounts: If you notice sudden changes in your benefit amount without a clear explanation, it could indicate an overpayment. Compare your current benefit payments to previous statements to identify any discrepancies.
  • Changes in Circumstances: Overpayments often result from changes in your circumstances, such as increases in income, changes in marital status, or improvements in your medical condition. If you fail to report these changes to the SSA promptly after they occur, it may lead to overpayment situations. Being aware of this and acting on any changes can help you avoid overpayments.
  • Errors in Calculation: Administrative errors or miscalculations by the SSA can sometimes cause overpayments. If you suspect that the overpayment resulted from a mistake, gather evidence to support your claim and seek assistance from an experienced disability attorney.
  • Third-Party Notices: In some cases, third-party entities, such as financial institutions or healthcare providers, may notify you of payments received on your behalf from the SSA that you were not entitled to receive. Take these Social Security overpayment letters seriously and investigate further to determine if you have been sent an overpayment.

How Do I Pay Back an Overpayment From Social Security?

Upon receiving an overpayment notice, you must act promptly. However, it’s not always easy knowing the correct steps to take. Follow this simple six-step process to ensure you act in your best interests.

Steps To Take Upon Receiving an Overpayment Notice

     1. Review the Accuracy of Information

Carefully examine the details provided in the overpayment notice. Verify the accuracy of your personal information, including your:

  • Name
  • Social Security number
  • Address

Make sure that the overpayment amount and dates within the notice align with your records.

     2. Validate the Overpayment

Take the time to assess whether you genuinely received more benefits than you were entitled to from the SSA. Review your financial records, benefit statements, and any relevant documentation to confirm the validity of the overpayment claim.

     3. Request Documentation

If the overpayment notice lacks sufficient information or clarity regarding the basis of the overpayment, consider requesting detailed documentation from the SSA to support their claim.

If you’re not sure how to do this, contact our disability lawyers in Arizona at 602-737-1022 and book a free phone, video call, or in-person consultation.

     4. Request a Waiver

If repaying the overpayment would cause you financial hardship or if you believe the overpayment was not your fault, you may be eligible for a waiver. Submit a formal request for a waiver to the SSA outlining the reasons for seeking relief, and provide supporting documentation.

     5. Negotiate a Payment Arrangement

If you acknowledge the overpayment but need assistance managing the repayment process, consider negotiating a payment arrangement with the SSA. You can propose a repayment plan, such as monthly installments or a lump-sum settlement, based on your financial circumstances.

     6. Seek Legal Guidance

Overpayment issues can be complex and difficult to navigate. Contact our Arizona disability attorneys at Pekas Smith: Arizona Disability Attorneys for guidance. Our legal team can assess your situation, explore your options, and represent your interests throughout the overpayment resolution process.

Repayment Options for Overpayments

Resolving an overpayment with the Social Security Administration (SSA) involves choosing the most suitable repayment option based on your financial situation. Here are the primary repayment options available:

  • Full Repayment: If you have the financial means to do so, paying the full amount upfront is often the quickest and simplest resolution. This option prevents accruing additional interest or penalties.
  • Partial Repayment: If paying the full amount at once is impossible, you may opt for partial repayment. This involves paying a portion of the overpayment upfront and negotiating a reasonable repayment plan for the remaining balance.
  • Repayment Plan: For individuals unable to afford a lump-sum payment, the SSA offers repayment plans tailored to your income and expenses. These plans allow you to repay the overpayment over time, typically through monthly installments.
  • Offset From Future Benefits: Sometimes, the SSA may withhold some of your ongoing benefits to recover the overpayment. This offset reduces your monthly benefit amount until the overpayment is fully recovered.
  • Third-Party Payer: If you cannot make payments directly, a third party, such as a family member or representative payee, may be able to assist with repayment on your behalf.

Requesting a Waiver for Overpayment Recovery

When facing overpayment recovery, individuals may find relief by requesting a waiver. This avenue is particularly crucial for those experiencing financial hardship or who believe the overpayment was not their fault. Let’s break down the process of requesting a waiver.

The first step is to fill out the Overpayment Recovery Request Form online. Complete the form detailing whether you reported changes in your financial situation and highlight reasons for demonstrating the overpayment was not your fault—this could be difficulty understanding the reporting requirements, memory challenges, etc.

Ensure you have reported your income and expenses accurately and fully and provide documentation for this if necessary.

If your waiver request is denied, seek reconsideration within 60 days by submitting a written request to the local Social Security office. If filed within 30 days, the SSA will suspend recovery efforts until your case is reviewed. During reconsideration, you can present new evidence to support your claim.

If the waiver is still rejected, request an Administrative Hearing within 60 days of the reconsideration decision. This can be done in writing or by filling out the Request for Hearing by Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) form. The hearing presided over by an Administrative Law Judge, provides an opportunity to present your case.

Appealing an Overpayment Decision

You have 60 days from receiving the Notice of Overpayment to file a reconsideration request.

However, if you submit your request within 30 days of receiving the notice, the Social Security Administration won’t seek repayment until after the reconsideration decision.

If you’re uncertain about the validity of the alleged overpayment, filing a reconsideration request compels the SSA to review your case again and clarify why it believes you were overpaid.

During the reconsideration phase, you can present evidence supporting your case in an informal hearing with a Social Security representative. If the SSA denies your reconsideration, indicating that the overpayment stands and must be repaid, you have 60 days to request a hearing before an Administrative Law Judge.

Should you receive an unfavorable ruling from the ALJ, you still have 60 days to pursue your final administrative appeal before the SSA’s Appeals Council.

If you’re facing a significant overpayment, it’s advisable to seek the assistance of an experienced disability attorney promptly upon receiving the notice. They can then help you handle your appeal.

Contact Our Arizona Disability Attorneys for Representation Today

At Pekas Smith: Arizona Disability Attorneys, we provide knowledgeable legal representation and support every step of the way. We have won millions of dollars in disability benefits for our clients, so we are confident that we can help you.

Contact us at 602.962.2818 for a free consultation to learn how we can help protect your rights and interests.

All of Arizona













and anywhere YOU are in AZ.
textured line

Choosing our Arizona Disability Attorneys provides advantages you can’t get from national firms and non-local advocates.


"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.